3,197
edits
Changes
→Implementation Phase
*** Confidential process should be conducted annually, even if there is no NomCom appointee who is re-applying. The process should be a peer-review method but separate from any 360-reviews conducted by some groups. The NomCom already has a third-party consultant to assess candidates. This same assessment process could be customized for re-applying candidates to include a confidential survey of the other members of the Board and other bodies on the re-applying candidates. This should also include the PTI Board.
*** Confidential process should be conducted annually, even if there is no NomCom appointee who is re-applying. The process should be a peer-review method but separate from any 360-reviews conducted by some groups. The NomCom already has a third-party consultant to assess candidates. This same assessment process could be customized for re-applying candidates to include a confidential survey of the other members of the Board and other bodies on the re-applying candidates. This should also include the PTI Board.
*** NomCom’s candidate evaluation and selection processes should be refined to automatically incorporate such feedback; NomCom members should be strongly discouraged from disregarding the feedback.
*** NomCom’s candidate evaluation and selection processes should be refined to automatically incorporate such feedback; NomCom members should be strongly discouraged from disregarding the feedback.
*** In the July 25 meeting of the IWG, [[Cheryl Landon-Orr]] noted that review of only NomCom appointees who are up for re-appointment would introduce a possibly insurmountable challenge to the NomCom's committment to confidentiality of personal data regarding candidates.<ref name="725mtg" />
*** In the July 25 meeting of the IWG, [[Cheryl Langdon-Orr]] noted that review of only NomCom appointees who are up for re-appointment would introduce a possibly insurmountable challenge to the NomCom's committment to confidentiality of personal data regarding candidates.<ref name="725mtg" />
* '''Recommendation 24''': An empowered body of current and former NomCom members should be formed to ensure greater continuity across NomComs, and in particular, to recommend and assist in implementing improvements to NomCom operations.
* '''Recommendation 24''': An empowered body of current and former NomCom members should be formed to ensure greater continuity across NomComs, and in particular, to recommend and assist in implementing improvements to NomCom operations.
** ''IWG Question to Community'': What process do you suggest should be put in place to help ensure cross-community consensus on developing the Charter and formation of this body? The Charter would address issues such as membership, term limits, number and allocation of seats?
** ''IWG Question to Community'': What process do you suggest should be put in place to help ensure cross-community consensus on developing the Charter and formation of this body? The Charter would address issues such as membership, term limits, number and allocation of seats?
''<noinclude>*</noinclude>Some comments were outside the scope of implementation planning and offered specific solutions to the issues underlying the recommendations. ICANN staff assisted in clarifying the relevant comments on each recommendation.''
''<noinclude>*</noinclude>Some comments were outside the scope of implementation planning and offered specific solutions to the issues underlying the recommendations. ICANN staff assisted in clarifying the relevant comments on each recommendation.''
Upon incorporating the community feedback on the six recommendations, and finalizing the remainder of the detailed plan, the IWG submitted its implementation plan to the board on September 15, 2019.<ref name="impplan" /> The plan was approved by the board at its meeting at [[ICANN 66]].<ref>[https://www.icann.org/resources/board-material/resolutions-2019-11-07-en#2.b Resolution of the Board], November 7, 2019</ref> The day before the board meeting, [[Tom Barrett]] of the IWG gave a brief update as to the status of the project and implementation to the ALAC.<ref>[https://66.schedule.icann.org/meetings/ePQ7BNobp3XcJbBC9 ICANN 66 Archive - At-Large Leadership Session: ATRT3 and NomCom2 Review Leadership Team], November 6, 2019</ref>
===Implementation Phase===
After approval of implementation plan, the IWG again contacted the SOs and ACs and constituent groups - along with the Board, the [[PTI]], NomCom support staff, and NomCom leadership - to solicit background information on each organization's "standard" activities and processes in interaction with the NomCom, using the final report's recommendations as a framework of inquiry.<ref>[https://community.icann.org/download/attachments/111383823/Implementation%20Outreach%20vfinal%2019122019.docx NomCom2 Workspace - Outreach Communications for Feedback on Implementation Steps], compiled December 19, 2019 (Word document)</ref> This elicited responses from across the community,<ref>[https://community.icann.org/download/attachments/126421147/Outreach%20Input%20Received%20v4.0.pdf NomCom2 Workspace - Implementation Outreach: Input Received], January 31, 2020</ref> which the IWG utilized to inform their work as they set about implementing improvements.
The IWG subsequently sent a proposed "rebalancing" plan (regarding Recommendation 10) to all GNSO stakeholder groups and constituencies, proposing that language regarding the specific allocation of GNSO seats be removed from the Bylaws, and empowering the GNSO to independently engage in a "rebalancing" process on a periodic bases. Such rebalancing, in the eyes of the IWG, was best conceived and implemented by the GNSO, in alignment with ICANN's principles of bottom-up, consensus action.<ref>[https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/nomcomriwg/2020-June/000472.html IWG to GNSO SG and constituency leadership], June 16, 2020</ref> The proposal was discussed during an SG/C leadership call,<ref name="rec10email">[https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/nomcomriwg/2020-October/000592.html IWG to GNSO SG/C leadership], October 9, 2020</ref> and written responses were sent by the [[BC]], [[IPC]], [[ISPCP]], and [[RySG]].<ref name="outreachdb">[https://community.icann.org/display/OR/Implementation+-+Outreach NomCom2 Workspace - Implementation: Outreach], last updated October 12, 2020</ref> The IWG also issued its first status report to the OEC in June.<ref name="status1">[https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/nomcom2-status-report-29jun20-en.pdf NomCom2 Implementation Status Report], June 29, 2020</ref> The status report detailed progress on initiating steps for most of the recommendations, and also laid out the input received from the ICANN community regarding implementation of specific recommendations.<ref name="status1" />
The second status report was submitted in December 2020.<ref name="status2">[https://community.icann.org/download/attachments/126421307/NomComRIWG%20Progress%20and%20Implementation%20Status%20Report%20%232%20-%2022%20December%202020.pdf NomCom2 Implementation Status Report], December 22, 2020</ref> The status report included proposed bylaws amendments in redline, as well as a draft charter for the standing committee for NomCom improvement.<ref name="status2" /> Progress was identified in implementation areas, and areas where further community engagment was required (such as Recommendations 10 and 27) were highlighted, and current steps described.<ref name="status2" /> Following the publication of the status report, and in line with the implementation plan for the recommendations requiring modification of the bylaws, ICANN Legal weighed in on the proposed bylaws amendments.<ref>[https://community.icann.org/display/OR/Implementation+Progress+Report?preview=/126421307/155191126/NomComRIWG%20Progress%20and%20Implementation%20Status%20Report%20%232%20-%2022%20December%202020%20-%20with%20legal%20tracked%20changes%20.docx NomCom2 Workspace - Second Implementation Status Report with ICANN Legal tracked changes]</ref>
As of June 2021, implementation is ongoing, with a third status report expected at the end of the month.<ref>[https://community.icann.org/display/OR/Implementation+Progress+Report NomCom2 Archive - Implementation Progress Reports], last updated January 15, 2021</ref>
==References==
==References==
[[Category:Organizational Reviews]]
[[Category:Organizational Reviews]]