Operating Standards for Specific Reviews: Difference between revisions

(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)

Line 28:

Following the February webinars, MSSI held a session on review operating standards at [[ICANN 58]] in Copenhagen.<ref name="icann58">[https://icann58copenhagen2017.sched.com/event/9nn7/icann-review-operating-standards-next-steps ICANN 58 Archive - ICANN Review Operating Standards: Next Steps], March 13, 2017</ref> The session was much shorter than its scheduled time, consisting largely of the presentation of material that echoed the themes of the February webinars. There was only one question, from [[Lito Ibarra]], regarding if or how the operating standards would discuss the scope of each of the specific reviews. Hoffman responded that Article 4.6 had provisions defining the scope of each of the specific reviews, so that the operating standards would likely not address that detail, and instead focus on processes where all reviews could benefit from a standard approach.<ref>[https://static.sched.com/hosted_files/icann58copenhagen2017/34/I58CPH_Mon13Mar2017-ICANN%20Review%20Operating%20Standards-Next%20Steps-en.pdf ICANN 58 Archive - Transcript, ICANN Review Operating Standards], March 13, 2017</ref>

==~~References~~==

Following the ICANN 58 session, the MSSI team developed a first draft that incorporated the community feedback, as well as offering "strawman" proposals for specific review processes. There was an informational display at [[ICANN 59]] regarding drafting progress, but no session was held at that meeting.<ref name="draft1web">[https://participate.icann.org/p5y3mb6nvk0/ Video Replay - Draft Operating Standards Webinar], October 19, 2017</ref> In addition, the [[Organizational Effectiveness Committee]] discussed both the first draft operating standards, and issues surrounding specific reviews that had been identified in conversation with leaders of the SOs and ACs. It was determined that the draft should be circulated first to SO/AC leadership prior to publication for public comment, and that the OEC meet with the SO/AC leadership at [[ICANN 60]] to further discuss the draft and the issues identified to date.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/resources/board-material/minutes-oec-2017-09-21-en OEC Meeting Minutes], September 21, 2017</ref> In a webinar, Lars Hoffman presented the state of the draft and provided some specific examples of the proposed processes for specific reviews. There were no comments or questions.<ref name="draft1web" />

~~{{reflist}}~~

===First Draft===

The first draft was published for public comment on October 17, 2017.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/public-comments/reviews-standards-2017-10-17-en ICANN.org Public Comment Archive - Draft Operating Standards for Specific Reviews], October 17, 2017 - February 16, 2018</ref> The public comment period was initially scheduled to end on January 15, 2018, but it was extended for an additional three weeks.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/en/announcements/details/public-comment-period-extended-operating-standards-for-icanns-specific-reviews-7-1-2018-en ICANN.org Announcement - Public Comment Period Extended, OSFR Draft, January 7, 2018</ref> At the time that the public comment period was extended, no public comments had been received.<ref>[https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/comments-reviews-standards-17oct17/ ICANN.org Listserv Archive - Public Comments, Draft Operating Standards for Specific Reviews]</ref>

===ICANN 60===

In Abu Dhabi, the cross community session<ref>[https://icann60abudhabi2017.sched.com/event/CbHX/cross-community-session-operating-standards-for-specific-reviews ICANN 60 Archive - Cross Community Session on Operating Standards for Specific Reviews], October 30, 2017</ref> on the draft Operating Standards was chaired by [[Cheryl Langdon-Orr]].<ref name="60trans">[https://static.sched.com/hosted_files/icann60abudhabi2017/14/I60AUH_Mon30Oct2017-CC%20Session%20-%20Operating%20Standards%20for%20Specific%20Reviews-en.pdf ICANN 60 Archive - Transcript, Cross Community Session on OSFR], October 30, 2017</ref> [[Thomas Rickert]] provided some background on the origins of the project, and discussed the activities of the [[Cross Community Working Group on Accountability]] in the aftermath of the [[IANA Transition]].

==References==

@@ Line 28: / Line 28: @@
 Following the February webinars, MSSI held a session on review operating standards at [[ICANN 58]] in Copenhagen.<ref name="icann58">[https://icann58copenhagen2017.sched.com/event/9nn7/icann-review-operating-standards-next-steps ICANN 58 Archive - ICANN Review Operating Standards: Next Steps], March 13, 2017</ref> The session was much shorter than its scheduled time, consisting largely of the presentation of material that echoed the themes of the February webinars. There was only one question, from [[Lito Ibarra]], regarding if or how the operating standards would discuss the scope of each of the specific reviews. Hoffman responded that Article 4.6 had provisions defining the scope of each of the specific reviews, so that the operating standards would likely not address that detail, and instead focus on processes where all reviews could benefit from a standard approach.<ref>[https://static.sched.com/hosted_files/icann58copenhagen2017/34/I58CPH_Mon13Mar2017-ICANN%20Review%20Operating%20Standards-Next%20Steps-en.pdf ICANN 58 Archive - Transcript, ICANN Review Operating Standards], March 13, 2017</ref>
-==References==
+Following the ICANN 58 session, the MSSI team developed a first draft that incorporated the community feedback, as well as offering "strawman" proposals for specific review processes. There was an informational display at [[ICANN 59]] regarding drafting progress, but no session was held at that meeting.<ref name="draft1web">[https://participate.icann.org/p5y3mb6nvk0/ Video Replay - Draft Operating Standards Webinar], October 19, 2017</ref> In addition, the [[Organizational Effectiveness Committee]] discussed both the first draft operating standards, and issues surrounding specific reviews that had been identified in conversation with leaders of the SOs and ACs. It was determined that the draft should be circulated first to SO/AC leadership prior to publication for public comment, and that the OEC meet with the SO/AC leadership at [[ICANN 60]] to further discuss the draft and the issues identified to date.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/resources/board-material/minutes-oec-2017-09-21-en OEC Meeting Minutes], September 21, 2017</ref> In a webinar, Lars Hoffman presented the state of the draft and provided some specific examples of the proposed processes for specific reviews. There were no comments or questions.<ref name="draft1web" />
-{{reflist}}
+===First Draft===
+The first draft was published for public comment on October 17, 2017.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/public-comments/reviews-standards-2017-10-17-en ICANN.org Public Comment Archive - Draft Operating Standards for Specific Reviews], October 17, 2017 - February 16, 2018</ref> The public comment period was initially scheduled to end on January 15, 2018, but it was extended for an additional three weeks.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/en/announcements/details/public-comment-period-extended-operating-standards-for-icanns-specific-reviews-7-1-2018-en ICANN.org Announcement - Public Comment Period Extended, OSFR Draft, January 7, 2018</ref> At the time that the public comment period was extended, no public comments had been received.<ref>[https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/comments-reviews-standards-17oct17/ ICANN.org Listserv Archive - Public Comments, Draft Operating Standards for Specific Reviews]</ref>
+===ICANN 60===
+In Abu Dhabi, the cross community session<ref>[https://icann60abudhabi2017.sched.com/event/CbHX/cross-community-session-operating-standards-for-specific-reviews ICANN 60 Archive - Cross Community Session on Operating Standards for Specific Reviews], October 30, 2017</ref> on the draft Operating Standards was chaired by [[Cheryl Langdon-Orr]].<ref name="60trans">[https://static.sched.com/hosted_files/icann60abudhabi2017/14/I60AUH_Mon30Oct2017-CC%20Session%20-%20Operating%20Standards%20for%20Specific%20Reviews-en.pdf ICANN 60 Archive - Transcript, Cross Community Session on OSFR], October 30, 2017</ref> [[Thomas Rickert]] provided some background on the origins of the project, and discussed the activities of the [[Cross Community Working Group on Accountability]] in the aftermath of the [[IANA Transition]].
 ==References==