Jump to content

.thai: Difference between revisions

From ICANNWiki
Wanawit (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{TLD|
{{TLD|
|logo  =
|logo  =
|status = Proposed
|status = Not Approved
|manager  =
|manager  =
|country  =  
|country  =  
Line 21: Line 21:


Its registration policies are: "Upon registration of a .thai domain name, a registrant must declare from where the proof of presence can be established, and what form of proof it is. A suggested list includes, but not limited to: nationality, business registration, organization, government, etc. BLM does not plan to validate the registrants’ proof-of-presence during the registration process, but rather will rely on the dispute resolution mechanism to allow interested users to dispute on the accuracy of the information."<ref>Application 1-2112-4478</ref>
Its registration policies are: "Upon registration of a .thai domain name, a registrant must declare from where the proof of presence can be established, and what form of proof it is. A suggested list includes, but not limited to: nationality, business registration, organization, government, etc. BLM does not plan to validate the registrants’ proof-of-presence during the registration process, but rather will rely on the dispute resolution mechanism to allow interested users to dispute on the accuracy of the information."<ref>Application 1-2112-4478</ref>
===Objection===
The Ministry of Information and Communication Technology, submitted the objection letter
[[File:letter1.jpg]]


==Objection==
The Thai Network Information Center Foundation ([[THNIC]]), which runs the [[ccTLD]] [[.th]], filed an objection against Better Living Management Company's application for .thai. It objects on the following three grounds:
The Thai Network Information Center Foundation ([[THNIC]]), which runs the [[ccTLD]] [[.th]], filed an objection against Better Living Management Company's application for .thai. It objects on the following three grounds:
# Better Living Management Company claims in their application to plan to work with THNIC, however THNIC says that no such agreement was made, and that it would not agree to such in the future, as BLM is for-profit and THNIC is non-profit.
# Better Living Management Company claims in their application to plan to work with THNIC, however THNIC says that no such agreement was made, and that it would not agree to such in the future, as BLM is for-profit and THNIC is non-profit.
# "Thai" is a transliteration of Thailand's [[IDN]] ccTLD, [[.ไทย]], and the two strings would be pronounced the same by a Thai reader, thus causing string similarity confusion.
# "Thai" is a transliteration of Thailand's [[IDN]] ccTLD, [[.ไทย]], and the two strings would be pronounced the same by a Thai reader, thus causing string similarity confusion.
# "Thai" is also commonly used by locals as a way to reference the country of Thailand.<ref>[https://gtldcomment.icann.org/comments-feedback/applicationcomment/commentdetails/6255 .thai Application Comment Details]</ref>
# "Thai" is also commonly used by locals as a way to reference the country of Thailand.<ref>[https://gtldcomment.icann.org/comments-feedback/applicationcomment/commentdetails/6255 .thai Application Comment Details]</ref>
Although the United States government initially opposed the [[GAC]] objection to geographic-looking strings such as .thai, they put out a statement in July 2013 that revised their position, saying it would remain neutral in the case of .thai, thereby allowing the GAC to present a consensus objection regarding the string and all of its [[IDN]] versions.<ref>[http://domainincite.com/13637-amazons-dot-brand-likely-doomed-as-us-withdraws-geo-objection?goback=%2Egde_1840166_member_255992449 Amazons dot brand  likely doomed, Domain Incite] Retrieved Oct 4 2013</ref>
==Rejection==
In November of 2013, [[ICANN]] designated the application as "Not Approved", meaning the application was formerly rejected by ICANN, who took the [[GAC]] objection into consideration. The application became only the 3rd one in the [[New gTLD Program]] to be formerly rejected.<ref>[http://domainincite.com/14999-icann-rejects-third-new-gtld-bid ICANN rejects 3rd New gTLD Bid, DomainIncite] Retrieved 12 Nov 2013</ref>


==References==
==References==

Latest revision as of 18:12, 12 November 2013

Status: Not Approved
Type: Community
Category: Culture

More information:

.thai is a proposed TLD in ICANN's New gTLD Program. The applicant is Better Living Management Company Limited.[1] It is a Community Priority Application.

It is a ethno-geographic TLD aimed at promoting and reinforcing the community of Thai people and speakers throughout Thailand and abroad. The applicant is a Thai company, however, it failed to file the Public Interest Community (PIC) which drove the government to object to the application which could create the sensitivity issue for Thai people, as 'Thai' is the name of the country, its language, culture and geographical origin of the product from Thailand.

Its registration policies are: "Upon registration of a .thai domain name, a registrant must declare from where the proof of presence can be established, and what form of proof it is. A suggested list includes, but not limited to: nationality, business registration, organization, government, etc. BLM does not plan to validate the registrants’ proof-of-presence during the registration process, but rather will rely on the dispute resolution mechanism to allow interested users to dispute on the accuracy of the information."[2]

Objection[edit | edit source]

The Thai Network Information Center Foundation (THNIC), which runs the ccTLD .th, filed an objection against Better Living Management Company's application for .thai. It objects on the following three grounds:

  1. Better Living Management Company claims in their application to plan to work with THNIC, however THNIC says that no such agreement was made, and that it would not agree to such in the future, as BLM is for-profit and THNIC is non-profit.
  2. "Thai" is a transliteration of Thailand's IDN ccTLD, .ไทย, and the two strings would be pronounced the same by a Thai reader, thus causing string similarity confusion.
  3. "Thai" is also commonly used by locals as a way to reference the country of Thailand.[3]

Although the United States government initially opposed the GAC objection to geographic-looking strings such as .thai, they put out a statement in July 2013 that revised their position, saying it would remain neutral in the case of .thai, thereby allowing the GAC to present a consensus objection regarding the string and all of its IDN versions.[4]

Rejection[edit | edit source]

In November of 2013, ICANN designated the application as "Not Approved", meaning the application was formerly rejected by ICANN, who took the GAC objection into consideration. The application became only the 3rd one in the New gTLD Program to be formerly rejected.[5]

References[edit | edit source]