− | Three separate minority statements were submitted to an Annex of the final report.<ref name="finalrep" /> All three expressed concern regarding the proposed changes to Article 4 reviews, as well as the accountability and transparency of the changes between the draft report to final report. The concerns expressed in these statements were the subject of a meeting between the ATRT3 implementation shepherds and a board caucus.<ref "wtfmeeting">[https://community.icann.org/display/atrt/ATRT3+Implementation+Shepherds?preview=/137921285/147851377/ATRT3%20BCG%208%20Sept%202020.doc ATRT3 Workspace - Transcript, Implementation Shepherd + Board Caucus Meeting], September 20, 2020</ref> In the meeting, the co-chairs of ATRT3, as well as board liaison [[Leon Sanchez]], member [[Sebastien Bachollet]], and member [[Vanda Scartezini]], all made similar points about the minority statements being more tied to the constituencies "behind" the authors, rather than the personal beliefs of the ATRT3 members themselves.<ref name="wtfmeeting" /> The board addressed these statements, and the conversation between the implementation and the board caucus, in its deliberation of the final report.<ref name="approveres" /> | + | Three separate minority statements were submitted to an Annex of the final report.<ref name="finalrep" /> All three expressed concern regarding the proposed changes to Article 4 reviews, as well as the accountability and transparency of the changes between the draft report to final report. The concerns expressed in these statements were the subject of a meeting between the ATRT3 implementation shepherds and a board caucus.<ref name="wtfmeeting">[https://community.icann.org/display/atrt/ATRT3+Implementation+Shepherds?preview=/137921285/147851377/ATRT3%20BCG%208%20Sept%202020.doc ATRT3 Workspace - Transcript, Implementation Shepherd + Board Caucus Meeting], September 20, 2020</ref> In the meeting, the co-chairs of ATRT3, as well as board liaison [[Leon Sanchez]], member [[Sebastien Bachollet]], and member [[Vanda Scartezini]], all made similar points about the minority statements being more tied to the constituencies "behind" the authors, rather than the personal beliefs of the ATRT3 members themselves.<ref name="wtfmeeting" /> The board addressed these statements, and the conversation between the implementation and the board caucus, in its deliberation of the final report.<ref name="approveres" /> |