Meta:Content Guide for ICANNWiki: Difference between revisions

(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)

Line 1:

This is the canonical '''Content Guide for ICANNWiki''', containing the rules and conventions that are to be used in the project~~. ''Last revised in July 2024''~~.

This is the canonical '''Content Guide for ICANNWiki''', containing the rules and conventions that are to be used in the project.

~~<div class="icannwiki-section-header">What you absolutely need to know</div>~~

'''''Last revision date''': {{#time:F|{{REVISIONTIMESTAMP}}}} {{REVISIONYEAR}}''.

~~<div class="icannwiki-colored-box icannwiki-justified">~~

* '''~~Base style for articles~~''':

** <span class="no-bullets">'''Article title''' (is/was) a (type of entity, like "registrar" or "lawyer"), [founded in (four-digits year)], originating from (country/territory). + (write any additional essential information to close off the leading paragraph) + (a new header follows with detailed content).</span>

* '''Scope''': ~~ICANN and Internet Governance are the subjects of the wiki. Avoid broad themes better covered elsewhere and focus on matters specific to these areas.~~

* '''Writing''':

** The wiki is in the English language, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).

** The editor's tone should always be neutral. Articles about services and businesses are welcome, but cannot be written in advertisement form.

* '''Notability''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or Internet governance.

* '''Lists of names''': ~~Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters.~~

~~</div>~~

Detailed explanations follow after the table of contents.

Line 38:

Line 30:

{| class="wikitable"

| '''Summary''':

* The wiki is in the English ~~lanugage~~, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).

* The wiki is in the English language, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).

* The editor's tone should always be neutral. Articles about services and businesses are welcome, but cannot be written in advertisement form.

|}

Line 45:

Line 37:

The main language of the wiki is English, and any variant of that language is accepted, with spellings such as ''color'' and ''colour'' being equally valid and with no need to normalize them. Our focus is on stabilizing the main version of the wiki before branching out to other languages, but exceptions can be made if they are coordinated with administrators.

In the case of companies, NGOs, and programs, the writing of ~~materials~~ relating to their work must be neutral, without marketing products or services. It is valid and welcome to state what an entity does and how that is related to Internet Governance or how that entity participates in ICANN. Entities are allowed to list their services, but that should not be done as a sales pitch. Occurrences of blatant marketing posting will be moderated.

In the case of companies, NGOs, and programs, the writing of entries relating to their work must be neutral, without marketing products or services. It is valid and welcome to state what an entity does and how that is related to Internet Governance or how that entity participates in ICANN. Entities are allowed to list their services, but that should not be done as a sales pitch. Occurrences of blatant marketing posting will be moderated.

===Notability===

{| class="wikitable"

| '''Summary''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or ~~Interent~~ governance.

| '''Summary''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or Internet governance.

|}

The criteria for notability of an article are that of being relevant to Internet Governance or ICANN in general, without the need for further qualification as long as that connection is firmly established. The bar is intentionally set lower than that of Wikipedia in order to accommodate concepts and community members that would not otherwise be fit to be included there. Be aware that the other criteria outlined above still hold, and blatant self-advertising will be edited out.

Line 55:

Line 47:

===Lists of names===

{| class="wikitable"

| '''Summary''': Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters.

| '''Summary''': Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters (ex.: members of Working Groups ''should'' be listed, winners of awards ''should not'').

|}

It is undesirable to include long lists of names on ICANNWiki that do not have a designated maintainer and are not directly connected to a relevant project, especially when the list is likely to change. Essential lists, such as those of members of the [[ICANN Board]], the [[GNSO Council]], and participants of [[Working Groups]], are allowed and encouraged due to the necessity of the information and the implicit expectation of their maintenance. Conversely, a list of recipients of a specific award for a particular year is undesirable unless the editor intends to compile a historical list of all recipients of the prize, which would make the list into more of an effort ~~for~~ content curation, rather than vanity editing.

It is undesirable to include long lists of names on ICANNWiki that do not have a designated maintainer and are not directly connected to a relevant project, especially when the list is likely to change. Essential lists, such as those of members of the [[ICANN Board]], the [[GNSO Council]], and participants of [[Working Groups]], are allowed and encouraged due to the necessity of the information and the implicit expectation of their maintenance. Conversely, a list of recipients of a specific award for a particular year is undesirable unless the editor intends to compile a historical list of all recipients of the prize, which would make the list into more of an effort of content curation, rather than vanity editing.

[[Category:ICANNWiki]]

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-This is the canonical '''Content Guide for ICANNWiki''', containing the rules and conventions that are to be used in the project. ''Last revised in July 2024''.
+This is the canonical '''Content Guide for ICANNWiki''', containing the rules and conventions that are to be used in the project.
-<div class="icannwiki-section-header">What you absolutely need to know</div>
+'''''Last revision date''': {{#time:F|{{REVISIONTIMESTAMP}}}} {{REVISIONYEAR}}''.
-<div class="icannwiki-colored-box icannwiki-justified">
-* '''Base style for articles''':
+{{Template:Must Know}}
-** <span class="no-bullets">'''Article title''' (is/was) a (type of entity, like "registrar" or "lawyer"), [founded in (four-digits year)], originating from (country/territory). + (write any additional essential information to close off the leading paragraph) + (a new header follows with detailed content).</span>
-* '''Scope''': ICANN and Internet Governance are the subjects of the wiki. Avoid broad themes better covered elsewhere and focus on matters specific to these areas.
-* '''Writing''':
-** The wiki is in the English language, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).
-** The editor's tone should always be neutral. Articles about services and businesses are welcome, but cannot be written in advertisement form.
-* '''Notability''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or Internet governance.
-* '''Lists of names''': Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters.
-</div>
 Detailed explanations follow after the table of contents.
@@ Line 38: / Line 30: @@
 {| class="wikitable"
 | '''Summary''':
-* The wiki is in the English lanugage, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).
+* The wiki is in the English language, all variants are accepted, as long as they are written in formal style (academic style not required).
 * The editor's tone should always be neutral. Articles about services and businesses are welcome, but cannot be written in advertisement form.
 |}
@@ Line 45: / Line 37: @@
 The main language of the wiki is English, and any variant of that language is accepted, with spellings such as ''color'' and ''colour'' being equally valid and with no need to normalize them. Our focus is on stabilizing the main version of the wiki before branching out to other languages, but exceptions can be made if they are coordinated with administrators.
-In the case of companies, NGOs, and programs, the writing of materials relating to their work must be neutral, without marketing products or services. It is valid and welcome to state what an entity does and how that is related to Internet Governance or how that entity participates in ICANN. Entities are allowed to list their services, but that should not be done as a sales pitch. Occurrences of blatant marketing posting will be moderated.
+In the case of companies, NGOs, and programs, the writing of entries relating to their work must be neutral, without marketing products or services. It is valid and welcome to state what an entity does and how that is related to Internet Governance or how that entity participates in ICANN. Entities are allowed to list their services, but that should not be done as a sales pitch. Occurrences of blatant marketing posting will be moderated.
 ===Notability===
 {| class="wikitable"
-| '''Summary''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or Interent governance.
+| '''Summary''': Low bar. The person, entity or concept needs to have a clear proven connection with ICANN or Internet governance.
 |}
 The criteria for notability of an article are that of being relevant to Internet Governance or ICANN in general, without the need for further qualification as long as that connection is firmly established. The bar is intentionally set lower than that of Wikipedia in order to accommodate concepts and community members that would not otherwise be fit to be included there. Be aware that the other criteria outlined above still hold, and blatant self-advertising will be edited out.
@@ Line 55: / Line 47: @@
 ===Lists of names===
 {| class="wikitable"
-| '''Summary''': Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters.
+| '''Summary''': Long lists of names are unwelcome, unless they pertain to essential matters (ex.: members of Working Groups ''should'' be listed, winners of awards ''should not'').
 |}
-It is undesirable to include long lists of names on ICANNWiki that do not have a designated maintainer and are not directly connected to a relevant project, especially when the list is likely to change. Essential lists, such as those of members of the [[ICANN Board]], the [[GNSO Council]], and participants of [[Working Groups]], are allowed and encouraged due to the necessity of the information and the implicit expectation of their maintenance. Conversely, a list of recipients of a specific award for a particular year is undesirable unless the editor intends to compile a historical list of all recipients of the prize, which would make the list into more of an effort for content curation, rather than vanity editing.
+It is undesirable to include long lists of names on ICANNWiki that do not have a designated maintainer and are not directly connected to a relevant project, especially when the list is likely to change. Essential lists, such as those of members of the [[ICANN Board]], the [[GNSO Council]], and participants of [[Working Groups]], are allowed and encouraged due to the necessity of the information and the implicit expectation of their maintenance. Conversely, a list of recipients of a specific award for a particular year is undesirable unless the editor intends to compile a historical list of all recipients of the prize, which would make the list into more of an effort of content curation, rather than vanity editing.
 [[Category:ICANNWiki]]