icannwiki

.health

Revision as of 22:29, 29 March 2013 by Andrew (talk | contribs) (→ALAC Objection)
Status: Proposed
Category: Health
More information:

.health is a proposed generic top level domain name (gTLD) in ICANN's New gTLD Program.

Applicants edit

  1. DotHealth, LLC - This applicant submitted a Public Interest Commitment, which can be downloaded here.
  2. Afilias, is a registry operator which also applied for TLDs on its own behalf.[1][2] This applicant submitted a Public Interest Commitment, which can be downloaded here.
  3. Famous Four Media (dot Health Limited), Geir Rasmussen is the contact person for the company, which has applied for 61 TLDs.[3][4] This applicant submitted a Public Interest Commitment, which can be downloaded here.
  4. Donuts (Goose Fest LLC), one of 307 applications submitted by the company. [5] This applicant submitted a Public Interest Commitment, which can be downloaded here.

GAC Early Warnings edit

Applicants for .health, were subject to a number of GAC Early Warnings.The warning system is noted as a strong recommendation on behalf of national governments to the ICANN Board that a given TLD application should be denied as it stands. Applicants are encouraged to work with objecting GAC members.[6]

France and Mali both objected to all four applications; France claims that the demands for legitimacy with regards to health services around the world prevents .health from being an easily deployable TLD, and that all applicants need greater security measures, they further note that: " We also refer to the requests from the World Health Organization NGOs, and others, who wrote to ICANN and the GAC to delay the attribution of the string to allow for consultation with the global health community on operating the TLD in the Public Interest."[7] Mali makes similar claims, and Cameroon also submitted an Early Warning to Afilias .health application, copying the French warning verbatim.[8]

Donuts replied to France´s warning to .health, and its similar objections for .architect, .sarl, .hotel and .vin, with an impassioned defense of the validity of open registration for New gTLDs.It notes that restricting registration unfairly assumes malfeasance on the part of the registrant, that no such restrictions exist for related domains in any exisiting gTLDs or ccTLDs, and that verification and restriction would inevitably raise the price of registration significantly. They go on to quote the GAC's own advice with regards to its contract with .xxx registry provider, ICM Registry, which notes that at that time the GAC was against any monitoring of TLD content given that it seems to overstep ICANN's technical mandate.[9]

European Commission Communiqué edit

The European Commission flagged all applicants for .health outside of ICANN's defined remediation processes.

Just after ICANN's GAC issued its Early Warnings, which are advice given from one GAC member country to an applicant warning it of potential issues within its application, the European Commission issued a letter to all applicants within the new gTLD program. The letter highlights 58 applications that "could raise issues of compatibility with the existing legislation .. and/or with policy positions and objectives of the European Union." It notes a desire to open a dialogue with each offending applicant.

The Commission specifically notes that this objection is not a part of the GAC Early Warning process, and goes on to note that "the Commission does not consider itself legally bound to [ICANN] processes," given that there is not legal agreement between the two bodies.[10][11]

ALAC Objection edit

In mid-February 2013, it was noted that the ALAC had intentions to file a formal objection against .health by the end of the month, stating that "Objection statements on community grounds will be drafted for the applications for .health given that the four tests for community objection grounds were passed." Their constituents argue that the string is a sensitive topic that should be managed carefully with input and management from international health organizations. They note that none of the applicants are community based, and that all of them represent for-profit ventures.[12]

It was not immediately clear whether there would also be objection filed to the mandarin version of the TLD, .健康, which was submitted by a separate venture than the 4 .health applicants. Later, it was revealed that while an objection to the string was suggested, there was no follow through on voting or objecting.

For some reason, Afilias' application for .health will not be receiving an ALAC objection while all other applicants will. Afilias managed to get one more "no" vote from the ALAC Board than other applicants, meaning that with only 50% voting "yes", the motion to object failed.[13]

IO Objections edit

ICANN's Independent Objector (IO) filed a Limited Public Interest objection against all of the applicants for .health. The IO is an appointed authority on international law whose role is to object to strings on the grounds of Community harm and Limited Public Interest were detailed in the applicant guidebook. His objections are official objections and are funded by ICANN, though his office is otherwise independent. Reasons for the specific case against .health were not initially given, but, in the case of Limited Public Interest, "the applied-for gTLD string must be contrary to generally accepted legal norms of morality and public order that are recognized under fundamental principles of international law. The expert panel appointed by the ICC will base its decision on the existence of such a contradiction." The applied for string must threaten an incitement to violence of lawless action, discrimination, child pornography, or "be contrary to specific principles of international law as reflected in relevant international instruments of law."[14]

The majority of the IO's objections are to health related TLD applications.


References edit

  1. ↑ Reveal Day 13 June 2012 – New gTLD Applied-For Strings
  2. ↑ Afilias Bringing Hundreds of New Top-Level Domains to the Internet
  3. ↑ Famous Four Media Applies, TheDomains.com
  4. ↑ Reveal Day 13 June 2012 – New gTLD Applied-For Strings
  5. ↑ Reveal Day 13 June 2012 – New gTLD Applied-For Strings
  6. ↑ GAC Early Warning, NewgTLDS.ICANN.org Retrieved 25 Nov 2012
  7. ↑ Health FR, GACweb.ICANN.org
  8. ↑ Health CM, GACWeb.ICANN.org
  9. ↑ Donuts reply to France, donuts.coPublished February 5 2013, Retrieved 8 Feb 2013
  10. ↑ DomainIncite.com/Docs Published 27 Nov 2012, Retrieved 11 Dec 2012
  11. ↑ Europe Rejects ICANNs Authority As it Warns of Problems with 58 New gTLDs, DomainIncite.com Published 27 Nov 2012, Retrieved 11 Dec 2012
  12. ↑ ALAC to submit Objection against Health, InternetNews.me Published and Retrieved 17 Feb 2013
  13. ↑ At Large Votes to Object to Health gTLD Bids but Afilias Gets a Pass, DomainIncite.com Published 15 March, Retrieved 29 march 2013
  14. ↑ Limited Public Interest, Independent Objector NewgTLDs.org Retrieved 14 Mar 2013

Governmental Advisory Committee. Considers and provides advice on the activities of ICANN as they relate to concerns of governments, particularly matters where there may be an interaction between ICANN's policies and various laws and international agreements or where they may affect public policy issues (ICANN Bylaws).

At-Large Advisory Committee. Considers and provides advice on the activities of ICANN related to the interests of individual Internet users (ICANN Bylaws). Not to be confused with the Non-Commercial Stakeholder Group.

Retrieved from "https://icannwiki.org/index.php?title=.health&oldid=76766"